Home / New Jersey / Highland Lake

Highland Lake, NJ

Elevation 1,276 ft

A typical 3-bed home in Highland Lake costs $427,765, about $129,131 less than in New Jersey.

Typical 3-bed home
$427,765
Price per sq ft
$363
Recent sales
27
Redfin, Aug–October 2026
Price trend
Up 3.2%
Typical home, Oct 2025–Oct 2026
How fast homes sell
32 days
Sale-to-list 103.1% · Redfin, August–October 2026

Agent tools: Town story card Where to move next Relocation packet House-poor handout

Are you a local agent? Claim Highland Lake

What's it like living in Highland Lake?

Insurance risk
Relatively Low
Strong wind, Cold wave, Winter weather · County level, not a premium
Where it is
Sussex County

The costs that keep coming in Highland Lake

After the price: what owners here pay in property tax, how everyday prices compare, electricity, and the county's hazard rating. Published figures for the town, area, county or state, not an estimate of anyone's bills.

Everyday prices
110.3
Goods prices in the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ area are 10.3% above the U.S. average. All items: 112.6.
BEA Regional Price Parities, 2024 (U.S. = 100)
Electricity
22.48¢ per kWh
Average residential bill in New Jersey: $128 a month.
EIA, state average, 2025 price and 2024 bill
Insurance risk
Relatively Low
Main hazards: Strong wind, Cold wave, Winter weather.
FEMA National Risk Index, December 2025, county rating. Not a premium or a price.

Work here

Unemployment
3.7%
Sussex County, Sep 2026 · BLS LAUS
Loading…

About this data

We couldn't match this city to a single Census place with confidence, so Census figures are left out rather than guessed.

Typical values: Zillow ZHVI, October 2026 (trend vs. October 2025). Sales, $/sq ft, days on market, and sale-to-list: Redfin, Aug–October 2026. Weather: NOAA 1991–2020. Distances are straight-line. Population, income, commute, earnings, industries, property tax, and median rent: ACS 2020–2024. Typical rent: Zillow ZORI, October 2026, when published. Dining & bars: Census CBP 2023. Unemployment: BLS LAUS, September 2026. Property tax rate: ACS 2020–2024 (B25103 ÷ B25077) when both exist. Insurance risk: FEMA National Risk Index, December 2025, county level, not a premium. Students per teacher: NCES CCD, 2024–25, when public schools can be matched to the town.

Value Score compares a town's typical home price with the U.S. typical home of the same size. 50 means the same price; higher means cheaper (100 would be free); below 50 means pricier.

Formula: 50 + 50 × (U.S. typical − town) ÷ U.S. typical.

What's the Value Score?